Feathering and the "marching ants"

  • When I make a selection, I see the "marching ants" where the selection is. If I grow/shrink the selection, I see the "marching ants" where the selection ends up.

    When I choose to Feather, it looks like the "marching ants" do not display the correct placement of the selection. For example, I start with this round selection on a tag :

    If I add a Feather to that selection, the "marching ants" show a smaller selection:

    That gives the impression that the selection is smaller than the original. However, if I fill that selection, it shows that the color extend the "marching ants" so I am getting an inaccurate representation of how much feathering I would actually need to achieve the result I want.

    Is that the normal and expected behavior on how the Feathering is displayed?

    To me, it looks completely opposite of what I would expect. In this format, I have no clue how much feathering I would need to stay within the dimensions of the tag, for example.

    I am using V3.0.3 on Windows 10 if it makes any difference.

  • I think that the marching ants show the point where the opacity (feathering) is at 50%, not the extreme outer bounds which would be a fraction of 1%, nor at the minimum where the opacity would be at 100%. I could be wrong about the cut off being 50% opacity.

    Mac Pro (Late 2013) Mac OS 12.7.6
    Affinity 3.0.1 | Affinity Designer 2.6.5 | Affinity Photo 2.6.5
    Affinity Publisher 2.6.5 | beta versions as they appear.

    I have never mastered color management, period, so I cannot help with that.

  • I think that the marching ants show the point where the opacity (feathering) is at 50%, not the extreme outer bounds which would be a fraction of 1%, nor at the minimum where the opacity would be at 100%. I could be wrong about the cut off being 50% opacity.

    Maybe so, but is there a way to know how far the selection is? It does not make sense to have only a partial "image" of the selection area.

    Is there another way to get that?

  • This threads contains 7 more posts that have been hidden for guests.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!